03.cat 2023 paper slot 1 varc
CAT 2023
The passage below is accompanied by four questions. Based on the passage, choose the best answer for each question.
[Fifty] years after its publication in English [in 1972], and just a year since [Marshall] Sahlins himself died—we may ask: why did [his essay] “Original Affluent Society” have such an impact, and how has it fared since? . . . Sahlins’s principal argument was simple but counterintuitive: before being driven into marginal environments by colonial powers, huntergatherers, or foragers, were not engaged in a desperate struggle for meager survival. Quite the contrary, they satisfied their needs with far less work than people in agricultural and industrial societies, leaving them more time to use as they wished. Hunters, he quipped, keep bankers’ hours. Refusing to maximize, many were “more concerned with games of chance than with chances of game.” . . . The so-called Neolithic Revolution, rather than improving life, imposed a harsher work regime and set in motion the long history of growing inequality . . .
Moreover, foragers had other options. The contemporary Hadza of Tanzania, who had long been surrounded by farmers, knew they had alternatives and rejected them. To Sahlins, this showed that foragers are not simply examples of human diversity or victimhood but something more profound: they demonstrated that societies make real choices. Culture, a way of living oriented around a distinctive set of values, manifests a fundamental principle of collective self-determination. . . .
But the point [of the essay] is not so much the empirical validity of the data—the real interest for most readers, after all, is not in foragers either today or in the Paleolithic—but rather its conceptual challenge to contemporary economic life and bourgeois individualism. The empirical served a philosophical and political project, a thought experiment and stimulus to the imagination of possibilities. With its title’s nod toward The Affluent Society (1958), economist John Kenneth Galbraith’s famously skeptical portrait of America’s postwar prosperity and inequality, and dripping with New Left contempt for consumerism, “The Original Affluent Society” brought this critical perspective to bear on the contemporary world. It did so through the classic anthropological move of showing that radical alternatives to the readers’ lives really exist. If the capitalist world seeks wealth through ever greater material production to meet infinitely expansive desires, foraging societies follow “the Zen road to affluence”: not by getting more, but by wanting less. If it seems that foragers have been left behind by “progress,” this is due only to the ethnocentric self-congratulation of the West. Rather than accumulate material goods, these societies are guided by other values: leisure, mobility, and above all, freedom. . . . Viewed in today’s context, of course, not every aspect of the essay has aged well. While acknowledging the violence of colonialism, racism, and dispossession, it does not thematize them as heavily as we might today. Rebuking evolutionary anthropologists for treating present-day foragers as “left behind” by progress, it too can succumb to the temptation to use them as proxies for the Paleolithic. Yet these characteristics should not distract us from appreciating Sahlins’s effort to show that if we want to conjure new possibilities, we need to learn about actually inhabitable worlds.
The author of the passage criticises Sahlins’s essay for its:
A.cursory treatment of the effects of racism and colonialism on societies.
B.failure to supplement its thesis with robust empirical data.
C.critique of anthropologists who disparage the choices of foragers in today’s society.
D.outdated values regarding present-day foragers versus ancient foraging communities.
Correct Answer
cursory treatment of the effects of racism and colonialism on societies.
Detailed Explanation
The passage under consideration does not explicitly criticize Marshall Sahlins's essay but rather reflects on the aspects of the essay that may not align with contemporary perspectives. One option suggests that the criticism lies in the cursory treatment of the effects of racism and colonialism on societies (Option 1). The passage does mention that, when viewed in today's context, not every aspect of the essay has aged well, particularly with regard to the treatment of issues such as colonialism and racism. It suggests that the essay does acknowledge these factors but perhaps does not emphasize them as much as might be expected in the current discourse.
Option 2 posits that the critique lies in the failure to supplement the essay's thesis with robust empirical data. However, the passage actually indicates that the empirical validity of the data is not the primary focus of the essay. It suggests that the essay's point is more about the conceptual challenge it poses to contemporary economic life and bourgeois individualism, using empirical data as a means to serve a philosophical and political project.
Option 3 suggests that the criticism pertains to Sahlins's essay critiquing anthropologists who disparage the choices of foragers in today’s society. This option does not align with the passage, as it emphasizes Sahlins's effort to showcase that foragers make real choices and that societies manifest a fundamental principle of collective self-determination. The essay is more about appreciating the choices of foragers rather than criticizing those who disparage them.
Lastly, Option 4 implies that the criticism revolves around outdated values regarding present-day foragers versus ancient foraging communities. While the passage does mention that not every aspect of the essay has aged well, the criticism is directed more toward the essay's treatment of issues like colonialism and racism rather than outdated values regarding foraging communities.
In summary, the most fitting interpretation of the passage is that the criticism, if any, lies in the essay's treatment of certain societal issues when viewed in today's context.
