Better Experience Download iQuanta App

Google Play
App Store
iQuanta Logo

12.cat 2023 paper slot 2 varc

The passage below is accompanied by four questions. Based on the passage, choose the best answer for each question. The Second Hand September campaign, led by Oxfam . . . seeks to encourage shopping at local organisations and charities as alternatives to fast fashion brands such as Primark and Boohoo in the name of saving our planet. As innocent as mindless scrolling through online shops may seem, such consumers are unintentionally—or perhaps even knowingly— contributing to an industry that uses more energy than aviation. . . . Brits buy more garments than any other country in Europe, so it comes as no shock that many of those clothes end up in UK landfills each year: 300,000 tonnes of them, to be exact. This waste of clothing is destructive to our planet, releasing greenhouse gasses as clothes are burnt as well as bleeding toxins and dyes into the surrounding soil and water. As ecologist Chelsea Rochman bluntly put it, “The mismanagement of our waste has even come back to haunt us on our dinner plate.” It’s not surprising, then, that people are scrambling for a solution, the most common of which is second-hand shopping. Retailers selling consigned clothing are currently expanding at a rapid rate . . . If everyone bought just one used item in a year, it would save 449 million lbs of waste, equivalent to the weight of 1 million Polar bears. “Thrifting” has increasingly become a trendy practice. London is home to many second-hand, or more commonly coined ‘vintage’, shops across the city from Bayswater to Brixton. So you’re cool and you care about the planet; you’ve killed two birds with one stone. But do people simply purchase a second-hand item, flash it on Instagram with #vintage and call it a day without considering whether what they are doing is actually effective? According to a study commissioned by Patagonia, for instance, older clothes shed more microfibres. These can end up in our rivers and seas after just one wash due to the worn material, thus contributing to microfibre pollution. To break it down, the amount of microfibres released by laundering 100,000 fleece jackets is equivalent to as many as 11,900 plastic grocery bags, and up to 40 per cent of that ends up in our oceans. . . . So where does this leave second-hand consumers? [They would be well advised to buy] high-quality items that shed less and last longer [as this] combats both microfibre pollution and excess garments ending up in landfills. . Luxury brands would rather not circulate their latest season stock around the globe to be sold at a cheaper price, which is why companies like ThredUP, a US fashion resale marketplace, have not yet caught on in the UK. There will always be a market for consignment but there is also a whole generation of people who have been taught that only buying new products is the norm; second-hand luxury goods are not in their psyche. Ben Whitaker, director at Liquidation Firm B-Stock, told Prospect that unless recycling becomes cost-effective and filters into mass production, with the right technology to partner it, “high-end retailers would rather put brand before sustainability.”

The central idea of the passage would be undermined if:

A.clothes were not thrown and burnt in landfills.
B.second-hand stores sold only high-quality clothes.
C.customers bought all their clothes online.
D.Primark and Boohoo recycled their clothes for vintage stores.

Correct Answer

second-hand stores sold only high-quality clothes.

Detailed Explanation

The central idea of the passage would be undermined if Option 2: second-hand stores sold only high-quality clothes. The passage discusses the benefits of thrifting as a counter to fast fashion, emphasizing the environmental savings and the reduction in waste. However, it also highlights the irony of older clothes shedding more microfibres, contributing to environmental problems. If second-hand stores sold only high-quality clothes that shed less and lasted longer, it would address one of the main concerns raised in the passage about the environmental impact of thrifting due to microfibre pollution. This change would strengthen the sustainability claim of second-hand shopping and reduce the irony of its unintended environmental consequences, thus undermining the passage's discussion of the complexities and unexpected issues associated with thrifting. The other options don't directly undermine the central idea of the passage: Option 1: While reducing waste in landfills is a goal of thrifting, the passage focuses on the broader issue of environmental impact and the irony of microfibre pollution. Not throwing and burning clothes in landfills doesn't address the nuanced discussion of thrifting's unintended consequences. Option 3: Customers buying all their clothes online doesn't directly relate to the environmental impact of thrifting or the irony of microfibre pollution from older clothes. Option 4: Primark and Boohoo recycling their clothes for vintage stores could potentially support the central idea by contributing to a more sustainable fashion cycle, rather than undermining the complexities and ironies associated with thrifting as discussed in the passage.