16.cat 2023 paper slot 2 varc
The passage below is accompanied by four questions. Based on the passage, choose the best answer for each question.
The Positivists, anxious to stake out their claim for history as a science, contributed the weight of their influence to the cult of facts. First ascertain the facts, said the positivists, then draw your conclusions from them. . . . This is what may [be] called the common-sense view of history. History consists of a corpus of ascertained facts. The facts are available to the historian in documents, inscriptions, and so on . . . [Sir George Clark] contrasted the "hard core of facts" in history with the surrounding pulp of disputable interpretation forgetting perhaps that the pulpy part of the fruit is more rewarding than the hard core. . . . It recalls the favourite dictum of the great liberal journalist C. P. Scott: "Facts are sacred, opinion is free.". . .
What is a historical fact? . . . According to the common-sense view, there are certain basic facts which are the same for all historians and which form, so to speak, the backbone of history—the fact, for example, that the Battle of Hastings was fought in 1066. But this view calls for two observations. In the first place, it is not with facts like these that the historian is primarily concerned. It is no doubt important to know that the great battle was fought in 1066 and not in 1065 or 1067, and that it was fought at Hastings and not at Eastbourne or Brighton. The historian must not get these things wrong. But [to] praise a historian for his accuracy is like praising an architect for using well-seasoned timber or properly mixed concrete in his building. It is a necessary condition of his work, but not his essential function. It is precisely for matters of this kind that the historian is entitled to rely on what have been called the "auxiliary sciences" of history—archaeology, epigraphy, numismatics, chronology, and so forth. . . .
The second observation is that the necessity to establish these basic facts rests not on any quality in the facts themselves, but on an apriori decision of the historian. In spite of C. P. Scott's motto, every journalist knows today that the most effective way to influence opinion is by the selection and arrangement of the appropriate facts. It used to be said that facts speak for themselves. This is, of course, untrue. The facts speak only when the historian calls on them: it is he who decides to which facts to give the floor, and in what order or context. . . . The only reason why we are interested to know that the battle was fought at Hastings in 1066 is that historians regard it as a major historical event. . . . Professor Talcott Parsons once called [science] "a selective system of cognitive orientations to reality." It might perhaps have been put more simply. But history is, among other things, that. The historian is necessarily selective. The belief in a hard core of historical facts existing objectively and independently of the interpretation of the historian is a preposterous fallacy, but one which it is very hard to eradicate.
All of the following describe the “common-sense view” of history, EXCEPT:
A.only the positivist methods can lead to credible historical knowledge.
B.history is like science: a selective system of cognitive orientations to reality.
C.history can be objective like the sciences if it is derived from historical facts.
D.real history can be found in ancient engravings and archival documents.
Correct Answer
history is like science: a selective system of cognitive orientations to reality.
Detailed Explanation
The passage discusses the common-sense view of history, primarily focusing on the role of facts in historical inquiry. Let's evaluate the options based on how they relate to or deviate from this common-sense view:
Option 1: Only the positivist methods can lead to credible historical knowledge.
The passage does associate positivism with a fact-based approach to history, but it doesn't explicitly state that only positivist methods are credible or that this is part of the common-sense view. The focus is more on the role of facts rather than strictly on positivist methods.
Option 2: History is like science: a selective system of cognitive orientations to reality.
This option does not describe the common-sense view as presented in the passage. The common-sense view is more about the accumulation of ascertained facts and doesn't delve into the idea of history as a selective system of cognitive orientations. This description seems to be more in line with the author's critique or a more nuanced view of history rather than the common-sense view, which is more straightforward and fact-focused.
Option 3: History can be objective like the sciences if it is derived from historical facts.
This option aligns with the common-sense view of history as presented in the passage. It emphasizes the accumulation and derivation of history from facts, suggesting objectivity similar to that in sciences.
Option 4: Real history can be found in ancient engravings and archival documents.
This option aligns with the common-sense view, which holds that history consists of a corpus of ascertained facts available to historians in documents, inscriptions, etc. It suggests that historical knowledge is sourced from tangible, factual evidence.
Based on the above analysis, Option 2 is the correct answer as it does not describe the common-sense view of history according to the passage. The common-sense view is portrayed as straightforward, fact-focused, and somewhat simplistic, not as a selective system of cognitive orientations to reality, which implies a more complex and interpretive approach.
