17.cat 2023 paper slot 3 varc
There is a sentence that is missing in the paragraph below. Look at the paragraph and decide where (option 1, 2, 3, or 4) the following sentence would best fit. Sentence: For theoretical purposes, arguments may be considered as freestanding entities, abstracted from their contexts of use in actual human activities. Paragraph : ___(1)___. An argument can be defined as a complex symbolic structure where some parts, known as the premises, offer support to another part, the conclusion. Alternatively, an argument can be viewed as a complex speech act consisting of one or more acts of premising (which assert propositions in favor of the conclusion), an act of concluding, and a stated or implicit marker (“hence”, “therefore”) that indicates that the conclusion follows from the premises.___(2)___. The relation of support between premises and conclusion can be cashed out in different ways: the premises may guarantee the truth of the conclusion, or make its truth more probable; the premises may imply the conclusion; the premises may make the conclusion more acceptable (or assertible).___(3)___. But depending on one’s explanatory goals, there is also much to be gained from considering arguments as they in fact occur in human communicative practices.___(4)___.
A.Option 3
B.Option 1
C.Option 2
D.Option 4
Correct Answer
Option 3
Detailed Explanation
Option 1: Placing the sentence here would introduce the theoretical perspective too early, before the paragraph has begun to define what an argument is. It's more logical to first understand what an argument is and then discuss the theoretical perspectives surrounding it.
Option 2: This option would interrupt the flow between defining an argument and explaining the different ways premises can support conclusions. It doesn't provide a natural transition or contrast at this point.
Option 3: This is the correct position, as it bridges the theoretical definitions and explanations of arguments with the upcoming discussion about the practical application of these theories in human communicative practices. It contrasts the theoretical abstraction with practical usage.
Option 4: Placing the sentence here would be after the discussion has already moved towards practical considerations. It would be less effective as it would disrupt the concluding thoughts on applying theoretical concepts to practical scenarios.
Therefore, Option 3 is the correct choice as it effectively transitions from theoretical discussions of arguments to considering their practical applications, underscoring the dual focus of theoretical abstraction and practical relevance in understanding arguments.
