When it comes to choosing between two iconic Indian B-schools like XLRI Jamshedpur vs IIM Lucknow, the decision can be anything but simple. Without a doubt, both these institutions have built solid reputations over decades in the Indian MBA context. Both the B-schools boast strong alumni networks and offer amazing placement support. For MBA aspirants, this choice can be solely personal yet significantly impactful. So how do you really choose between the two? Let us try to find the answer below. In this blog, we aim to unpack the differences on multiple factors. These will include brand value, academic excellence, campus life, batch profiles and of course, placements. This article will help you make a decision that is not just strategic but also well in-line with your personal and professional goals.
Brand and Legacy
XLRI Jamshedpur: Established way back in 1949, XLRI (Xavier School of Management) is the oldest management institute in India. It was founded by the Jesuit society in collaboration with the Tatas having the vision to inculcate ethical and responsible leadership. Over the decades, it has built a unique identity based on ethics, academic excellence and a strong industry connect. XLRI excel particularly in the fields of Human Resources (HR) and Marketing.
IIM Lucknow: Founded in 1984, IIM Lucknow is the fourth IIM to be established in India after the holy trinity, IIM Ahmedabad, Bangalore and Calcutta. It has been able to be one of the best since its inception and is now considered a part of the “Top-5 IIMs Club.” The brand carries immense value, both in India and abroad. IIM Lucknow is particularly known for its academic rigour and intense culture in the campus
Verdict: While XLRI commands unparalleled dominance in HR, IIM Lucknow’s broader brand value as an IIM, especially for finance, consulting can be a compelling edge for a few of us.
Join this free whatsapp group to get the latest information about CAT exam along with the strategies by CAT experts
Location Advantage
XLRI Jamshedpur: Located in the steel city of Jamshedpur, XLRI offers a focused and distraction-free environment. Though there is connectivity via rail and road, air connectivity is still lacking to Jamshedpur (Ranchi being the nearest airport). However, Jamshedpur as a city in collaboration with Tatas provide all the amenities to the campus and leaves no stones unturned in providing students with all the required comfort.
IIM Lucknow: Situated in the capital of Uttar Pradesh, the IIM Lucknow campus is well-connected by road, rail and air. Additionally, being in close proximity to the national capital, IIM Lucknow does have a slight edge when it comes to the locational advantage.
Verdict: IIM Lucknow benefits slightly more from urban access, but XLRI’s unique campus experience offers uninterrupted academic excellence.
Campus Life and Student Culture
XLRI: Known for its highly tight-knit and passionate community, XLRI promotes strong 3-batch culture when it comes to bonding. National fests like Ensemble-Valhalla and cultural nights are deeply student-driven and happen frequently to keep up the campus vibe. XLRI also comes with a strong social ethics and sense of purpose which sets it apart. They majorly do this through programs like Rural Immersion and on campus committees like Social Initiatives Group for Managerial Assistance (SIGMA).
IIM Lucknow: Life at IIM L is surely known for its intense and transformative culture. With clubs for nearly every domain, be it finance, analytics, literature, or dance. Additionally, their flagship events like Manfest-Varchasva and other events, the campus life is always lively.
Verdict: XLRI offers a relatively chiller learning environment with deep bonding, while IIM Lucknow presents a hustle culture with intense academic rigour like classes around all days in a week.
Academic Orientation and Curriculum
XLRI: They offer two flagship programs: PGDM in Business Management (BM) and PGDM in Human Resource Management (HRM). XLRI’s curriculum is very deeply rooted in ethics, leadership and sustainability. This is to ensure that there is strong emphasis on real-world application through these degrees. The HR program is considered the best in Asia, drawing attention from top recruiters across the country and abroad.
IIM Lucknow: Offers the Post Graduate Programme in Management (PGP) along with specialized tracks in Agri-Business (PGP-ABM) and Sustainable Management (PGP-SM). The pedagogy for all the 3 programs is case-based and the academic intensity is consistent across all the programs. PGP – ABM has pool placements along with the PGP batch, making it equally compelling for the aspirants
Verdict: XLRI is surely a niche when it comes HR related roles. However, IIM Lucknow is more diverse yet niche when it comes to programs like ABM and SM.
Join this free whatsapp group to get the latest information about CAT exam along with the strategies by CAT experts
Batch Profile: Diversity that Drives Learning
Gender Diversity
| Institute | Male (%) | Female (%) | Notable Mention |
| XLRI Jamshedpur | 64% | 36% | Consistently working toward better gender parity – More females than males in HRM program (57% is female) |
| IIM Lucknow | 68% | 32% | Improving female representation year-on-year |
Observation: XLRI without a doubt has a slight edge in gender diversity. It leads to meaningful contributing to more balanced classroom discussions and other team dynamics.
Academic Background
| Academic Stream | XLRI (%) | IIM Lucknow (%) |
| Engineering | ~60% | ~65% |
| Commerce & Economics | ~20% | ~15% |
| Science, Arts, Others | ~20% | ~20% |
Though these are approximate figures basis trends of the last few years, this is fairly correct.
Work Experience
| Work Experience (Months) | XLRI (%) | IIM Lucknow (%) |
| Freshers | 28% | 30% |
| 0–11 | 10% | 14% |
| 12–23 | 28% | 20% |
| 24–36 | 23% | 22% |
| 36+ | 11% | 14% |
Verdict: Both institutes offer a very good mix of freshers and experienced professionals, which an essential part of peer-to-peer learning. However, XLRI tends to attract more students with non-engineering backgrounds to ensure academic diversity.
Placement Reports 2023–25: A Comparative Snapshot
Key Metrics
| Metric | XLRI Jamshedpur | IIM Lucknow |
| Highest CTC | ₹ 1.1 CPA | ₹ 65 LPA |
| Average CTC | ₹ 31.08 LPA | ₹ 32.3 LPA |
| Median CTC | ₹ 29 LPA | ₹ 30 LPA |
| Total Recruiters | 172 | 190 |
| PPO Conversion | 35% | 33% |
Domain-wise Placements
Consulting
| Aspect | XLRI | IIM Lucknow |
| Avg. CTC | ₹34–35 LPA | ₹34–36 LPA |
| Key Recruiters | BCG, Bain, Accenture, EY-Parthenon, Vector Consulting | McKinsey, BCG, Bain, Accenture, EY-Parthenon |
Finance
| Aspect | XLRI | IIM Lucknow |
| Avg. CTC | ₹30–32 LPA | ₹31–33 LPA |
| Key Recruiters | JP Morgan and Chase, RMB, Goldman Sachs, Citi, Standard Chartered | Deutsche Bank, JPMorgan, Axis Capital |
Join this free whatsapp group to get the latest information about CAT exam along with the strategies by CAT experts
Sales & Marketing
| Aspect | XLRI | IIM Lucknow |
| Avg. CTC | ₹28-32 LPA | ₹28–30 LPA |
| Key Recruiters | P&G, HUL, ITC, Nestle, Reckitt | P&G, HUL, Asian Paints, Dabur |
HR (Specialized)
| Aspect | XLRI HRM Only | IIM Lucknow (General HR Roles) |
| Avg. CTC | ₹28–30 LPA | ₹22–24 LPA |
| Key Recruiters | ITC, Airtel, Aditya Birla, Vedanta | Tata Steel, L&T, ICICI, Capgemini |
Verdict: Both schools offer excellent outcomes. However, XLRI leads in HR by a great margin, while IIM Lucknow edges out in Finance field.
XLRI Jamshedpur vs IIM Lucknow – Alumni Network: Your Lifelong Advantage
XLRI Alumni:
- Spread across top leadership roles in HR, General Management and Strategy
- Known for strong loyalty and community. Also known as XL Mafia.
- Deep reach in HR, FMCG, BFSI and Government sectors
IIM Lucknow Alumni:
- Pan-industry presence: Consulting, Finance and Technology
- Strong networking across all IIMs
- Representation in global firms like Amazon, McKinsey, BCG, to name a few
Verdict: Both these colleges offer a very strong alum base. However, XLRI having a legacy of 76 years edges out IIM Lucknow to an extent. That will be a way to see XLRI Jamshedpur vs IIM Lucknow.
Final Thoughts: Which One Should You Choose?
Choosing between XLRI Jamshedpur and IIM Lucknow is less about “which is better” and more about what aligns best with your career goals, values, and learning preferences. If you see a career in HR or leadership roles, XLRI should be your choice. Similarly, if Finance attracts you more, picking IIM Lucknow can be a smarter choice. Other than that, if you are hell bend for the IIM tag, IIM Lucknow can be your pick. In short, pick a college basis your personal preferences and professional aspirations. Hence, whichever of XLRI Jamshedpur vs IIM Lucknow you pick, you will not regret the decision. So, instead of asking “Which is better?”, ask: “Which one fits me better?”
Join the Largest CAT Preparation Community in India
